Add a question Add

Unless he was inspired, how could Joseph Smith achieve incredible and complex internal consistency while dictating the Book of Mormon?

This is another piece of evidence to keep in mind when approaching all the other facts. 

In 2020, Jeff Markham documented 120 internal consistencies in the Book of Mormon. When taken as a whole they are impressive and require a strong explanation as to how Joseph Smith managed it. Some of the internal consistencies are complex and span large parts of the Book of Mormon (up to 239 chapters earlier), others are subtle but show a comprehensive understanding of the plot.

Keeping track of hundreds of names, events, timelines, visions, sermons, physical items, geography, etc. is a huge undertaking for any author, let alone one without any notes. 

Would we really expect this kind of internal consistency from Joseph? Wouldn’t Joseph have needed pages and pages of notes just to ensure internal consistency? If Joseph had taken time to ensure all this internal consistency then why didn’t he draw attention to it?

See: 

Add
Add a Question
Submit
Thank you for your submission